Comparing Ships
Comparing Ships
I have attached (hopefully) a simple excel spreadsheet which allows a comparison between any two cruisers in the USN tree. Try it please. Any feedback welcome.
Cheers
Taipan17
Taipan17- Captain
- Posts : 30
Join date : 2016-01-03
Age : 53
Location : Hervey Bay QLD
Re: Comparing Ships
Taipan17 wrote:Hi,
I have attached (hopefully) a simple excel spreadsheet which allows a comparison between any two cruisers in the USN tree. Try it please. Any feedback welcome.
Cheers
Taipan17
Looking into "Attach Files" function Taipan. Standby.
Dan
Re: Comparing Ships
Cheers
Dan
USN Cruiser line comparisons
This is a very basic version to test the waters. I have been expanding it to include other country's cruiser trees, in addition to the costs calculator mentioned above
Cheers
- Attachments
Last edited by Taipan17 on Tue Feb 02, 2016 12:13 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : Attach Excel file.)
Taipan17- Captain
- Posts : 30
Join date : 2016-01-03
Age : 53
Location : Hervey Bay QLD
Re: Comparing Ships
Tip: Make sure you click on "Submit Query" next to your Browse button when uploading your File...then wait. After the file is uploaded then hit Post and the file should appear. The Submit Query function is automatic to make sure that your file complies to the parameters allowable by our forum.
Try again Taipan and we'll see if it works.
Cheers
Dan
Re: Comparing Ships
I took a look at this last night (glad we finally worked out our Attachments issues) I really like the idea. We had a similar thing for Axis & Allies - War at Sea cards, to see comparative differences at a glance gives players a better understanding of the various units.
Strengths and weaknesses between the vessels I would be interested in particular between the various nations. I guess for my part between KM & IJN ships since I only play with USN and RN units. Some IJN units (Cruisers in particular) demonstrate a clear advantage in fire power and survivability to USN units of the same tier. It would be interesting to see exactly what those differences are at a glance.
In history, Naval officers were made quite aware of (known) enemy units (strengths and weaknesses) and could recognize them by silhouette, knowing what you are up against in advance certainly helps in combatting your enemy. I think over time we are all learning the various ships by engaging with them regularly, for example as a St Louis skipper the units I probably fear the most are NOT battleships but Phoenix and Karlsrhue both out range me and have faster reload speed, it helps to know these units before choosing whether or not to engage them.
Great resource Taipan, great job sar.
Dan